Animals eat lichen in bulk, and that is where your answer starts. A 2023 PLOS ONE study puts ground-dwelling lichen at 75% of the caribou winter diet and about 25% of the summer diet. So the honest starting point on edible lichens is that animals eat them by the herd. Herders in the north gather lichen too, so their reindeer have feed when snow covers everything else. What you get from these sources is a record of that use. Not one of them signs off on a species as safe for your own dinner.
The chemistry is what makes this awkward for you. Lichens make about 400 known secondary products. Those compounds are thought to be defenses against disease and parasites, and they also deter herbivory. Read that second job again, because it works against you. A good share of lichen chemistry is there to stop animals eating the lichen, and that is a strange foundation for a foraging habit.
You have a second issue, and it has nothing to do with what the lichen builds on its own. Lichens have no waxy cuticle to seal them off, so everything around them passes straight into their structure. They trap particulate matter and pull in sulfur, mercury and nitrogen, and all of it stays in the tissue. So your question splits in two. One half is the chemistry a lichen made. The other half is what it collected from the air, and a species with mild chemistry growing in dirty air still holds every bit of what it pulled in. That double source is why edible lichens are hard to judge on sight.
The record of lichen as food is mostly a record of animals, not of people like you. Sheep in the deserts of Libya get part of their living from crustose lichens on bare rock, scraping a meal off stone where almost nothing else grows. Elk and moose feed on lichen too, so you can add them to the caribou herds. The caribou numbers shift with the season. Lichen makes up three quarters of their winter diet and a quarter of the summer one, so the share falls once other forage comes back.
Reindeer lichen food is the clearest human case you will find in this set. The Lapp people harvest lichens and hold them as winter feed for their reindeer, which makes lichen a fodder crop rather than a human staple. That is feeding, not foraging. People do the cutting and the storing, and the animals do the eating. The practice shows you that lichen carries a reindeer through a hard season, which is the whole point of winter feed. It tells you nothing about what the same handful does in a person.
So treat lichen as animal fodder and not foraging material. These sources give you no portion size, no preparation method and no list of species cleared for people, and you should not build one out of them by guessing. If a foraging guide puts a lichen on your plate, that guide is your source, and this page is not.
These sources document lichen eaten by animals and harvested as fodder. They do not clear any species for people and they do not give you an amount.
The 400 compounds are the part worth chasing. Some of them already reach you as anti-viral and anti-bacterial medications. That is a separate question with its own body of work, so head to the medicinal use question if the chemistry is what brought you here. Edible lichens and useful lichen compounds are not the same subject. On the eating side, the evidence stops where it stops.
Read the full article: Lichens: What They Are and How to Spot Them