What are the three types of hedges?

picture of Benjamin Miller
Benjamin Miller
picture of Charles Hartman
Charles Hartman
Published:
Updated:

Gardeners name formal, informal, and mixed or native. That is the standard answer, and the three types of hedges you see quoted online come from garden usage rather than an official list. Look for hedge types explained by a university extension service and the split stops at two, formal and informal. The mixed group turns up in wildlife guidance instead, so treat the number as a handy grouping, not a rule.

From the kitchen window this morning, four goldfinches were working the seed heads in a run of hawthorn, dogwood and elder along the back fence. A wren went in low and did not come out. That same tangle hides the neighbor's driveway, which is why I planted it, and it holds food and cover for birds through the cold months.

What separates the groupings is easy to see once you know where to look. Formal is defined by the shearing, informal by pruning that keeps the plant's own shape, and the mixed or native run by carrying several species at once. The first two describe how you cut. The third describes what you plant, and that is why it is the grouping that shrugs off a pest capable of wiping out a single species planting.

Formal is the sheared kind, cut to a set outline, and the plants go in close at 1 to 2.5 feet (30 to 76 cm) apart so they knit into one wall. Holding that line takes two or more shears a year, for as long as you own the place. Informal hedges get spaced by their mature width instead. They need occasional pruning rather than a set schedule, so the flowers and fruit stay on the plant instead of going out with the clippings.

Both cutting styles stay thick on the same treatment. Cut out one-third to one-fourth of the oldest branches each year, close to the ground, and fresh stems come up to fill the gap. Skip that for a decade and you get the classic problem hedge, bare and woody at knee height and heavy on top. Renovation from that point is a multi-year job, so the yearly cut is the cheap option.

A mixed species hedge is the third grouping, and it changes what the planting can do. You put three or four kinds down the line instead of one shrub repeated forty times. Iowa State University Extension rates a mix as more resilient to insect and disease problems than a single species run. Natives get the nod too, where you can find them. When something does come through, it takes a share of the hedge rather than the whole thing.

A native hedgerow is where the wildlife side stacks up. Habitat, food, cover and a connected route between patches of ground come with the planting, along with shelter for the beneficial insects that patrol your vegetable beds. It still screens the road and still works as a barrier for stock or foot traffic, and it stores carbon while it does the rest of the job.

The Three Groupings Compared
GroupingFormalCutting
Two or more shears a year
Spacing1 to 2.5 feet (30 to 76 cm)
GroupingInformalCutting
Occasional pruning
SpacingBy mature width
GroupingMixed or nativeCutting
Occasional pruning
SpacingBy mature width

Pick by workload and by width. Formal buys you a sharp, narrow edge and charges you the shears twice a season, which is why my own front boundary is short. Informal costs you a wider strip of yard and hands most of your weekends back. The mixed planting wants the most room of the three and pays back the most, since it carries the wildlife value and spreads the pest risk across several species. No source I trust fixes the number at three, so use it as a starting point and plant what your boundary can hold.

Read the full article: Hedges: Plant, Shape and Keep Them Dense

Continue reading