How can you tell a lichen from moss?

picture of Nguyen Minh
Nguyen Minh
picture of Charles Hartman
Charles Hartman
Published:
Updated:

Look for leaves. Moss carries tiny green leaves on stems, small but real, and a lichen has none at all. That one check settles lichen vs moss on almost any rock, trunk or fence rail you walk past. A lichen is not a plant. It is two organisms living as one, a fungus paired with an alga or a cyanobacterium, and the fungal partner builds the whole body you see.

I pulled a hand lens along the split-rail fence at the bottom of the yard last April, rail by weathered rail. The green fuzz on the shaded face broke into hundreds of little leaves spiraling up short stems. A few inches along, a pale gray crust lay flat against the wood, and I found no leaves in it anywhere. Just a skin over a colored layer, gripped to the grain by rhizines.

The difference between lichen and moss is a difference in body plan. Moss grows parts you can name, leaves and stems, and you can trace one leaf back to the stem it sits on. A lichen has three layers instead. There is a cortex on the outside, an algal layer under it that does the feeding, and a loose medulla of fungal threads below that. Rhizines hold the lichen onto bark, but they move no water at all, and the body has no xylem, no phloem and no waxy skin to seal moisture in.

Three checks identify lichen in the field, and the first one takes a hand lens. Start with the leaves. Moss shows them at once, in tidy spirals running up each stem, and a lichen never will, no matter how green and mossy the patch looks from a step back. See no leaves at ten times magnification and you are not looking at moss.

Then wet a small patch and wait a minute. Moss stays the same green it already was, while a gray lichen flushes bright green as the cortex cells turn clear and the algae underneath show through. A lichen with a cyanobacterial partner goes dark green, brown or black instead. The swing is that sharp because a dry lichen soaks up 3 to 35 times its own weight in water, a range measured at the Intermountain Herbarium at Utah State University. Nothing with a waxy cuticle can drink like that.

The third check is shape, and it settles lichen vs moss at arm's length. Lichens grow in three main forms, and once you can name them you stop second-guessing gray patches on stone.

Three Lichen Growth Forms
FormCrustoseWhat You See
Lies flat, like spilled paint
Common SpotStone, headstones, roof tile
FormFolioseWhat You See
Leafy lobes with curling edges
Common SpotTree bark, old fence rails
FormFruticoseWhat You See
Shrubby or hanging, fully 3D
Common SpotBranches, twigs, damp woods

Moss never takes any of those shapes. It makes a low cushion or a loose mat of upright shoots, soft and even across the patch, and you can pull one stem free with your fingers and see the leaves running up it. A crustose lichen will not come away like that. You have to scrape it, and the crust breaks instead of lifting, because it has grown into the surface rather than sitting on top of it. Foliose lobes do peel, and they tear like wet paper.

Both grow on the same trunk and the same wall, often on one board, so check a small area rather than judging the whole patch from a distance. Pick a spot you can cover with the lens and work that square. Mixed cover is normal on old rails and on shaded north-facing bark. Finding both is not a failed call. It tells you the wood stays damp and nobody has scraped it in years.

Read the full article: Lichens: What They Are and How to Spot Them

Continue reading