Why put a potato in the bird feeder?

picture of Liu Xiaohui
Liu Xiaohui
Published:
Updated:

Some gardeners put a potato in bird feeder stations to give birds extra moisture and starch. The potato bird feeder trick is simple. You cut a potato in half and set it on a feeder spike or platform tray. Birds peck at the soft flesh for hydration and quick energy when your yard's food or water runs low.

I tried this myself last winter by sticking a halved russet potato on the spike of my platform feeder. Over five days of watching, I saw mixed results. A couple of starlings pecked at the exposed flesh on day two. One mockingbird showed some interest on day three. But my cardinals, finches, and chickadees ignored it. They went straight for the sunflower seeds in the tray next to it. By day five, the potato had dried out and started to look rough.

Raw potato for birds provides some carbs and moisture, but it's far from ideal. Birds need high-fat, high-protein foods to fuel their fast metabolism. Potatoes don't deliver on either front for your feathered visitors. A raw potato is about 80% water with mostly starch and very little bird-friendly nutrition. It works as a small supplement during dry spells. But it can't replace the seeds, suet, and insects that your birds need most.

One big warning here: never put cooked potato in your feeder. Cooked potatoes often have salt, butter, oil, or seasoning on them that can harm birds. Salt is toxic to most small birds even in small amounts. Raw potato is safe for birds to peck at, but anything you've prepared for human meals should stay off the feeder.

Bird experts recommend proven foods over unusual bird feeding tips like potatoes. Black oil sunflower seeds attract the widest range of species to your yard. Suet cakes work great for woodpeckers and nuthatches during cold months. Fresh fruit like apple halves and orange slices bring in orioles and tanagers. You'll get far better results from these foods than from any potato. Decades of research show they keep your birds healthy and coming back.

If you enjoy trying unusual bird feeding tips, you have better options than potatoes. Uncooked oats scattered on a platform feeder attract ground-feeding birds like juncos and doves. Unsalted peanuts in the shell give jays and woodpeckers a protein-rich treat they'll fight over. Dried mealworms bring in bluebirds and wrens that you might not see at a regular seed feeder. These options all beat a raw potato for both nutrition and bird interest.

Your best backyard bird setup pairs a good feeder with a nearby bird bath. The feeder handles the food side with seeds, suet, and fruit. The bird bath gives your visitors the water they need for drinking and bathing. You'll attract far more species this way than any potato trick could manage on its own. Spend your money on a bag of black oil sunflower seeds and a simple bird bath, and you'll have birds lining up in your yard all year long.

Read the full article: Bird Bath Guide for Your Garden

Continue reading