Are all conifers trees?

picture of Nguyen Minh
Nguyen Minh
picture of Martin Thorne
Martin Thorne
Published:
Updated:

No. Being a conifer is about cones and seeds, not about height or a single trunk. Conifer shrubs share a bench at the nursery with pines that outgrow a house, and you get the same word on both labels for the same reason. Botanists count 638 species in the group, and what ties them together is how they carry seed. Height is no part of the definition. Some creep flat across your gravel. Others you clip into a hedge every summer. All of them count.

The shallow stone trough by my back step holds three conifers, and none will ever throw shade. I set the plants into gritty mix one March, wedged a few small rocks around the collars, and walked away. Each tag printed height and width at 10 years on the back instead of a mature size, which is how nurseries sell the small selections. You see the same plants grown for rock gardens, troughs and containers, and the trough has held its shape through every winter since.

Those 10-year figures come from a framework the American Conifer Society set up. You get four classes out of that framework: miniature, dwarf, semi-dwarf and large, sorted by growth rate and by how big a plant stands at 10 years old. Nothing in that split is botanical. A plant tagged dwarf is not a separate kind of plant, and lists of dwarf conifers describe habit and size class rather than family tree. Your knee-high spruce and the spruce that clears your roofline are the same thing in botanical terms, because both carry seed in cones. So the tag in your hand describes size and shape, not a botanical rank.

Walk a garden center and you can see the point on the benches. Arborvitae gets grown and clipped as a hedge, and you find conifer shrubs sitting on the same list as juniper, yew and cypress. A juniper ground cover runs flat over your slope and never puts up a trunk at all. Others form low mats or tight mounds you could step over without noticing. Habit does not decide the group. Creeping junipers get sold for covering a bank, and none of those plants will ever look like a tree. A conifer that stays below your knee is as much a conifer as a fir in a forest.

The mix-up comes from the picture in your head. Say conifer and you think of a tall evergreen with a point on top, because that is what a Christmas tree looks like and what fills a timber plantation. The definition sits in the seed cone though, and you find cones on plants of every shape and size. Conifers sit inside the gymnosperms, and that whole group is defined by seed cones rather than by stature. Shape had no say. The plants under that one word run from flat mats to forest giants.

The number worth trusting on a plant tag is size at 10 years, not the single mature height printed in big type on the front. Many conifer shrubs keep creeping along for decades, so a mature figure can be a guess or a number taken from a much older specimen. Ten-year size tells you what your shrub will do in the spot you have, which is the question you brought to the nursery in the first place.

Treat the growth rates and hardiness ratings on those tags as nursery guidance, not settled botany. The numbers come from how a selection has behaved in trial beds and gardens, and your own soil and exposure will move them around. So shop by habit first and by name second. If you want something low beside a path, ask for a miniature and check the 10-year width as well, since width crowds a walkway before height ever matters to you.

Read the full article: Conifers: Types, Traits, and Hard Numbers

Continue reading