What are the two types of hedges?

picture of Benjamin Miller
Benjamin Miller
picture of Charles Hartman
Charles Hartman
Published:
Updated:

You have two choices, formal and informal hedges. A formal one you shear to a set outline, and it holds that shape right through the season. An informal one keeps the shape the shrub grows on its own, and you give it a light prune to hold the size you want. Your pick has little to do with which shrub goes in the ground. It comes down to how often you cut.

Start with the workload, because that gap runs much wider than the gap in looks. A formal hedge needs shearing two or more times a year, and you have to keep that up every year. Skip a round and the outline blurs, so you lose the reason you planted it. An informal hedge asks you for occasional pruning and little else.

Spacing splits the two as well, and you set that on planting day. The formal type goes in tight, 1 to 2.5 feet (30 to 76 cm) apart, so the shrubs knit into one wall you can shear as a single surface. For an informal hedge you space by the mature width of each plant. Give them that room and they fill the gaps for you as they grow.

Shearing works on the skin of your plant. Each cut across the outer surface wakes the buds sitting right behind it, and those buds push new shoots, so the outer layer turns thick and twiggy. That dense skin is what hands a formal hedge its hard edge. It also costs you flowers. The wood that would have bloomed keeps getting clipped off before it can open, and that is the trade you make for a crisp line.

What Iowa State Tells Homeowners

Iowa State University Extension says, "Most home gardeners would benefit most from selecting an informal hedge, as the maintenance requirements for a formal hedge are almost always more than anticipated."

I would put that in blunter words. The look is easy to want in March and easy to drop by August, once the shears feel heavy and the weekends fill up. Be honest with yourself about how many Saturdays you will hand this hedge, and your choice gets simple.

Formal Versus Informal
Formal, Sheared
  • Sheared two or more times a year to hold one crisp outline.
  • Trimmed while the season's shoots are still soft.
  • Planted tight so the shrubs knit into a single wall.
  • Gives up most of its bloom to the shears.
Informal, Natural
  • Pruned now and then, with a light thinning once a year.
  • Shaped just enough to hold the size you want.
  • Spaced by the mature width of each plant.
  • Keeps its flowers, since the blooming wood stays on.

Upkeep is where a sheared hedge catches you out. Clip it while the new growth is still green and soft, and work those sessions into your summer the way you plan the mowing. Your informal hedge wants annual thinning and shaping to keep it in bounds, and you can leave it alone the rest of the year.

Both types want the same favor once a year from you. Cut out one-third to one-fourth of the oldest branches near the ground, and your hedge stays vigorous whichever look you picked. Do not shear more than once a year without alternating that thinning. Shearing on its own pushes excess new growth, and it can reduce your flowers.

Here is the rule I use. Pick formal only where the hard line is the whole point, like a clipped wall along a front walk. And pick it only if you know you will shear it twice a year, in heat and in a busy week. Everywhere else, plant informal. You keep the flowers, and your shrubs still look right in the long stretch between prunings.

Read the full article: Hedges: Plant, Shape and Keep Them Dense

Continue reading