Most common hedge plants fall into two camps, and picking a camp settles half the job before you dig a hole. On the evergreen side you meet boxwood, yew, holly, arborvitae, laurel and privet. On the deciduous side it is beech, hornbeam, hawthorn and lilac. The same names turn up in guide after guide for a plain reason. They take shearing, they hold a shape for years, and you can find them on the bench at almost any garden center.
The lane behind my own house smells of wet leaf litter every October. Green beech sits in the middle of that mixed run and holds bronze leaves all winter, while the hawthorn two plants down stands bare and black. I planted two of those beech myself. Something in that hedge is always sick, and the run has still never had a gap in it. Iowa State University Extension backs that up. Mixed-species hedges hold up better against insect and disease problems than single-species ones, and natives are the first choice where you can get them.
Evergreen hedge plants do their work in January, when everything around them is sticks. Yew clips to a tight, dark face and lives a very long time, which is why you still see it around churchyards and old walled gardens. Boxwood clips down to a low edge tight enough for a knot garden. Holly puts spines along a boundary where you want people to keep out, and the berries feed birds through late winter. Arborvitae stacks into a narrow column for a tight side yard, laurel throws out big glossy leaves that block a view with fewer plants, and privet does the plain green job with the least fuss.
Many evergreens will not resprout from leafless wood. An overgrown yew or arborvitae has to be brought back over several seasons, not cut to a stump in one go.
Deciduous hedging drops its leaves, which sounds like a flaw until you see the trade you get for it. Clipped beech and hornbeam hang onto their dead foliage through winter, so the screen turns copper instead of bare. Hawthorn builds a thorny barrier that turns back livestock and shelters nesting birds. Lilac is the loose one. It is more flowering shrub than wall, and it fits a boundary you never plan to shear into a straight line. Bare stems also let winter light through to whatever is planted behind them, and in a small yard that light is worth something.
Which of the common hedge plants you pick matters less than how far apart you set them. Mature size is the number that decides it, and the size of the pot you carry home tells you nothing at all. A shrub that finishes at 6 to 8 feet (1.8 to 2.4 m) goes in 2 to 4 feet (0.6 to 1.2 m) apart in an informal hedge. One heading for 8 to 12 feet (2.4 to 3.7 m) needs 4 to 6 feet (1.2 to 1.8 m) between plants. Crowd them and the shrubs spend their whole lives fighting each other for the same ground.
Plant a mixed hedge of three or four species and a pest that would open a gap in a single-species run reaches only the plants it feeds on. That is the whole argument for mixing. USDA NRCS asks two things of a hedge species. It has to be adapted to the site, and it must not host pests or diseases that threaten nearby crops. So check what the orchard or field next door is fighting before you place an order, and buy what you can already see doing well on the fence lines around you.
Read the full article: Hedges: Plant, Shape and Keep Them Dense