Vinegar does not kill bindweed. It burns the leaves and stems it wets, and that is where the whole effect stops. The roots below never feel a thing. A homemade bindweed killer mixed from pantry vinegar, salt and dish soap behaves the same way. So does the stronger horticultural grade you can buy in jugs at the garden center. Spraying vinegar on bindweed buys you about three weeks of bare dirt, not a dead plant.
The timing is what gives the trick away. You spray a patch at noon, and by evening the leaves have gone limp and gray, which reads like a clean kill. The ground stays bare for a while and you start to believe it worked. Then the shoots come back. Bindweed pushes up new top growth about 3 weeks after the old growth is destroyed, and those vines are the same plant feeding off the same roots.
The gap between what you see and what happened is a matter of how the spray moves. A contact weed killer damages only the tissue it lands on, and acetic acid is about as simple an example as you will find. It strips the protective coat off the leaf, the cells dry out, and the leaf is dead in hours. Nothing travels past the wet spot. A systemic product does a different job. It gets pulled inside the leaf and rides the plant's own sugar flow down into the roots, which is the only part of a bindweed that decides whether your weed lives.
- Kills only the leaf and stem tissue the spray wets.
- Visible damage in hours, regrowth in about 3 weeks.
- No effect at all on the root system underground.
- Best suited to cracks and gravel where nothing needs to live.
- Moves with the sugar flow from leaf down into the roots.
- Works slower and looks like nothing is happening at first.
- Reaches root buds that a surface spray cannot touch.
- Still needs several repeat treatments over more than one season.
The root numbers explain why the plant keeps beating you. UC IPM puts bindweed's vertical roots at 20 feet (6 m) or more, and roots able to bud new shoots turn up as deep as 14 feet (4 m). About 70% of the root mass sits in the top 2 feet (60 cm) of soil, close enough to push a replacement vine up fast. The plant has a second layer of defense on top of that. The surface of its leaves and stems forms a barrier that blocks many herbicides from being absorbed and carried through the plant at all.
Vinegar concentrated enough to scorch a weed will scorch whatever else it drifts onto. It takes out lawn edges, hosta leaves and the perennials you were trying to save, and it stings skin and eyes on contact. Wear gloves and eye protection, and spray only on a still day.
So what actually works? Repeat removal is the honest low-tech answer. Cut or pull every shoot as soon as you see it, and keep at it on roughly a 3 week cycle, so the roots spend stored food on regrowth they never get to earn back. Light exclusion does the same job for you with far less labor. Lay cardboard and a thick mulch over the patch, or a solid tarp, and leave it there for three to five years.
Your third route is a systemic spot treatment at the right time. Products labeled for this weed include 2,4-D, dicamba, picloram, glyphosate and quinclorac. Of that group, quinclorac and picloram work best. One pass never clears an old stand. Bindweed regrows after spraying, even when you use a labeled systemic, so plan on several repeat treatments over more than one season.
Keep your vinegar for driveway cracks and gravel paths where nothing needs to survive. Vinegar on bindweed is a cosmetic fix with a three week shelf life. The green comes back. The roots are no weaker than the day you sprayed, and you have spent a whole season getting nowhere underground.
Read the full article: How to Get Rid of Bindweed: 7 Real Fixes